Explore the lesson here. Canvas holds your check-ins, submissions, feedback, and progress.
Return to this lessonMilestone 1 · after Unit 3
Problem and feasible scope
A snapshot of the same project record.
Submit or review the first snapshot of the same project record. Show a specific need, the user and responsible decision owner, a traceable evidence log, numerical baseline, three alternatives, a justified AI capability choice, and a bounded charter. Reuse the discovery work rather than write a separate background paper.
A complete classroom case is equivalent to a partner context for practicing these criteria. Label supplied facts, role-play, observations, and assumptions accurately. A compelling technology description without a worthwhile task does not meet the goal.
In an instructor-led offering, obtain scope feedback before substantial building. The rubric weights below divide this milestone; the milestone contributes 15% in the proposed full-course model. Self-paced review does not imply a grade.
| Criterion | Maximum points | Meets the goal | Strong transfer | Scoring anchors |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Problem and stakeholder fit | 25 | Names a specific user, responsible decision owner, recurring task, consequence, and current alternative. | Explains differing stakeholder needs and uses contrary evidence to refine the problem. | Strong evidence: 25; Meets the goal: 20; Developing: 12.5; Not demonstrated: 0. Intermediate points within this criterion's maximum are allowed when the instructor explains the criterion-specific evidence. |
| Evidence and numerical baseline | 30 | Important claims have traceable sources or assumption labels; counts, units, denominator, and baseline interpretation are correct. | Distinguishes need, performance, and adoption evidence and identifies the missing observation most likely to change the judgment. | Strong evidence: 30; Meets the goal: 24; Developing: 15; Not demonstrated: 0. Intermediate points within this criterion's maximum are allowed when the instructor explains the criterion-specific evidence. |
| Alternatives and feasible scope | 30 | Compares current practice, a simple improvement, and an AI candidate with consistent criteria; bounds one task, AI capability, input/output, no-code route, resources, and exclusions. | Tests a consequential uncertain assumption and explains why the preferred learning investment changes or remains stable. | Strong evidence: 30; Meets the goal: 24; Developing: 15; Not demonstrated: 0. Intermediate points within this criterion's maximum are allowed when the instructor explains the criterion-specific evidence. |
| Decision and communication | 15 | States a testable question, quality boundary, next step, and clear evidence/AI-use disclosure. | Makes the chain from evidence to scope easy to inspect and explains a meaningful revision after discovery. | Strong evidence: 15; Meets the goal: 12; Developing: 7.5; Not demonstrated: 0. Intermediate points within this criterion's maximum are allowed when the instructor explains the criterion-specific evidence. |
How criterion scores are assigned
Each rubric criterion keeps its published maximum points. The instructor judges the evidence against that criterion's Meets the goal and Stronger evidence descriptions and uses these numerical anchors.
| Evidence level | Anchor | What the evidence shows |
|---|---|---|
| Strong evidence | 100% of the criterion maximum | Meets the goal and demonstrates the criterion's stronger evidence or transfer. |
| Meets the goal | 80% of the criterion maximum | Demonstrates the stated goal with accurate, usable evidence. |
| Developing | 50% of the criterion maximum | Shows a relevant attempt, but important evidence is incomplete, unreliable, or needs correction. |
| Not demonstrated | 0% of the criterion maximum | Provides no usable evidence for this criterion. |
These are judgment anchors, not automatic all-or-nothing ratings. Intermediate points are allowed within the criterion maximum, with a comment identifying the evidence and remaining gap. For a 25-point criterion the anchors are 25, 20, 12.5 and 0 points. A defensible decision to narrow, revise, or stop can earn strong credit. These anchors do not change criterion maximums, assessment totals, course weights, or previously recorded scores.
A favorable project result is not required; the quality of evidence and judgment matters.