Explore the lesson here. Canvas holds your check-ins, submissions, feedback, and progress.

Milestone 3 · after Unit 7

Pilot and learning

A snapshot of the same project record.

Show the predeclared pilot question and measures, actual user-task record, defensible comparison, complete effort and quality, meaningful revision, and retest. Keep supplied benchmark figures separate from what happened with your version.

The result may support continuation, narrowing, or stopping. Grade quality of evaluation and judgment, not a positive AI result. The individual explanation near this milestone is ungraded formative preparation. The individual case exam is the sole assessed 40-point individual component within Milestone 5; this earlier explanation contributes no separate score.

Milestone 3 rubric
CriterionMaximum pointsMeets the goalStrong transferScoring anchors
Test design and comparison25Defines version, user task, permitted inputs, baseline/comparison, quality, full-process timing, and decision rules before observing outcomes.Addresses order, practice, case differences, or selection effects and explains what the design can and cannot establish.Strong evidence: 25; Meets the goal: 20; Developing: 12.5; Not demonstrated: 0. Intermediate points within this criterion's maximum are allowed when the instructor explains the criterion-specific evidence.
Actual observation and quantitative integrity30Records an actual classroom or partner attempt with assistance, completion, quality, complete effort, units, denominators, and missing values correctly labeled.Uses an inspectable table/figure to expose an exception or tradeoff hidden by a favorable average and reconciles it with the recommendation.Strong evidence: 30; Meets the goal: 24; Developing: 15; Not demonstrated: 0. Intermediate points within this criterion's maximum are allowed when the instructor explains the criterion-specific evidence.
Meaningful revision and retest25Links a consequential finding to a changed artifact or process and documents an actual retest of the affected path.Checks transfer to a changed case and an unaffected path, explaining any new limitation rather than only reporting success.Strong evidence: 25; Meets the goal: 20; Developing: 12.5; Not demonstrated: 0. Intermediate points within this criterion's maximum are allowed when the instructor explains the criterion-specific evidence.
Interpretation and next decision20Separates supplied from observed evidence, states limitations, and gives a proportionate continue/revise/stop decision.Considers an alternative explanation and identifies the next evidence that would most reduce uncertainty.Strong evidence: 20; Meets the goal: 16; Developing: 10; Not demonstrated: 0. Intermediate points within this criterion's maximum are allowed when the instructor explains the criterion-specific evidence.

How criterion scores are assigned

Each rubric criterion keeps its published maximum points. The instructor judges the evidence against that criterion's Meets the goal and Stronger evidence descriptions and uses these numerical anchors.

Scoring anchors within each criterion's maximum
Evidence levelAnchorWhat the evidence shows
Strong evidence100% of the criterion maximumMeets the goal and demonstrates the criterion's stronger evidence or transfer.
Meets the goal80% of the criterion maximumDemonstrates the stated goal with accurate, usable evidence.
Developing50% of the criterion maximumShows a relevant attempt, but important evidence is incomplete, unreliable, or needs correction.
Not demonstrated0% of the criterion maximumProvides no usable evidence for this criterion.

These are judgment anchors, not automatic all-or-nothing ratings. Intermediate points are allowed within the criterion maximum, with a comment identifying the evidence and remaining gap. For a 25-point criterion the anchors are 25, 20, 12.5 and 0 points. A defensible decision to narrow, revise, or stop can earn strong credit. These anchors do not change criterion maximums, assessment totals, course weights, or previously recorded scores.

A favorable project result is not required; the quality of evidence and judgment matters.

Before saving this snapshot

Return to the Finish step →