Explore the lesson here. Canvas holds your check-ins, submissions, feedback, and progress.

← Learning path

Unit 03 of 12

Choose and scope a solution

Which response fits the need, uncertainty, and resources?

Learn

By the end of this unit

  • Compare current practice, a simpler improvement, and an AI-assisted candidate on the same criteria.
  • Define a bounded task and a decision that evidence can change.

Planned guided work including the short textbook read-and-apply: 83–133 minutes, plus other project work. This is a design estimate, not measured learner time.

How to read this lesson

The labels describe how to use a passage. Color does not prove a claim is true or that a response is correct.

  • Explain — Understand the idea.
  • Try / predict — Make a choice or prediction before the reveal.
  • Evidence — Inspect the named source or supplied data.
  • Worked reasoning — Compare the steps after your own attempt.
  • Caution — Check a limit, assumption or unsupported conclusion.

Each figure has its own local legend for the data. Blue selection outlines mark the current selection; other outlines are explained by each figure’s local legend. Selection is not a correctness judgment.

Explain

Choose a learning investment before a large commitment

A worthwhile problem does not automatically require AI. Cedar Desk could organize its policy card, provide a checked reply template, or use AI to adapt a draft to a question. Compare these against the same need. A convenient tool with unclear review responsibilities may be a worse first investment than a well-organized source sheet.

Three original classroom options; effects are hypotheses until tested
OptionPotential benefitMain uncertaintySmallest useful test
Current processKnown responsibilities and owner review.Where does processing effort go?Time the complete task on agreed cases.
Source card and templatesEasier access to approved facts.Can users select the correct condition?Try ordinary and boundary cases.
Reviewed AI reply kitAdapts a draft to the question.Does checking erase drafting gains?Compare the same cases, including review and rework.

First screen for feasibility: permitted information, available tools, a reviewer, and time to test. Then compare value, evidence, effort, and consequences. A score is a recorded judgment, not a measurement of future impact. Explain what evidence would justify changing it. An option that cannot meet a quality boundary does not become acceptable by receiving a high convenience score.

Set one primary task: a coordinator uses ReplyKit to produce a checked reply or an owner-ready exception note. Exclude processing refunds, changing bookings, live customer messages, and owner decisions. A useful scope is small enough to complete and broad enough to include the actual handoff.

See the decision

Where did the six saved minutes go?

Try / predict

Predict the complete effort before revealing the work around the draft.

Supplied case

A fictional planning comparison. The same task must finish with a checked reply or a useful handoff; drafting alone is not the result.

Complete effort, minutes per reply
ComponentPlanning estimate
Manual complete task8
AI draft2
Source checking3
Correction2
Handoff1
Assisted complete task8
Worked reasoning

The 2-minute draft needs 6 more minutes of work:2+3+2+1=8. It has no full-process time advantage in this scenario. Checking at 2 minutes would yield 7 minutes, or 12.5% less effort, only if quality remains acceptable. The template-only alternative still needs measurement.

Use it in your project: In your scope comparison, identify the overlooked step most likely to change the recommendation.

Required textbook reading and application · about 18 minutes

Read, then apply one idea

Read only the passages listed here. Mathematical derivations, algorithms, code, and end-of-chapter exercises are not assigned. The time estimate includes the brief passage and one connection to your existing project update; reading the passage alone usually takes much less time. It is a planning estimate, not a timer.

1.6.3: Defining a Solution

David L. Poole and Alan K. Mackworth. Artificial Intelligence: Foundations of Computational Agents. 3rd edition. Cambridge University Press, 2023.

Read: Go to 1.6.3 Defining a Solution. Read from that heading through the Optimal solution and Satisficing solution entries. Stop before Approximately optimal solution. Earlier 1.6 subsections and later Representations are not assigned.

Why this unit: Shows why informal requests need explicit success criteria, limits, and consequences for incomplete or incorrect outputs.

11.3: Conducting a Feasibility Analysis

Michael Laverty and Chris Littel. Entrepreneurship. 1st edition. OpenStax, Rice University, 2020.

Read: Read the opening explanation and Organizational Feasibility Analysis only. Stop at Financial Feasibility Analysis. Do not prepare a business plan or financial statements.

Why this unit: Evaluate whether people, skills and resources can support the proposed scope.

Course connection: A first solution should solve one bounded task well enough for a stated use. Write a minimum acceptable result, not a promise that the AI is always right. Consider whether a simpler checklist, template, search tool, or process change would meet the need without AI.

Course connection: Feasibility is separate from usefulness. A community, personal, research or business solution needs both a worthwhile task and a practicable way to perform it.

Apply one idea: Choose one prompt for the brief connection in your existing project update.

  • Write one measurable acceptance rule, one task outside the scope, and one costly mistake the solution must avoid. Explain why AI is useful here compared with a simpler alternative.
  • Name one resource or skill constraint that changes the scope of your AI solution.
Read this textbook section here

The official page below may include material before or after your assigned selection. The reader does not automatically scroll or crop to that selection.

Assigned selection — 1.6.3: Defining a Solution: Go to 1.6.3 Defining a Solution. Read from that heading through the Optimal solution and Satisficing solution entries. Stop before Approximately optimal solution. Earlier 1.6 subsections and later Representations are not assigned.

Official textbook section ↗

Read this textbook section here

The official page below may include material before or after your assigned selection. The reader does not automatically scroll or crop to that selection.

Assigned selection — 11.3: Conducting a Feasibility Analysis: Read the opening explanation and Organizational Feasibility Analysis only. Stop at Financial Feasibility Analysis. Do not prepare a business plan or financial statements.

Official textbook section ↗

Add a brief connection to your existing project update: identify the book and section, explain one relevant idea in your own words, and show the decision it informs. This is part of the same update, not another assignment.

If the official reader is unavailable or inaccessible, use the original lesson explanation and worked example, apply the same question, and label that access alternative honestly. Report the problem through the course support route; do not claim to have read an unavailable text.

Optional further reading

Strategyzer — How to select the next best test ↗

Read the experiment-selection principles and the discovery/validation distinction. Name the uncertainty your next test addresses. The article’s suggested experiment cadence is not an added course requirement.

Try

Try / predict

Find the assumption that changes the recommendation

A fictional planning estimate puts manual handling at 8 minutes per reply. An AI draft takes 2 minutes, checking 3, correction 2, and handoff 1. Predict the saving before adding: 2 + 3 + 2 + 1 = 8. Faster drafting has produced no full-process time gain. If checking falls to 2 minutes without reducing quality, the total becomes 7 and the possible gain is 1 minute. That change needs evidence.

A defensible selection statement

“Compare the organized template and reviewed AI candidate on the same twelve supplied cases. Keep commitments under human control. Select continued use only after checking total effort, material errors, and the coordinator’s ability to use the kit. We have not selected a live system or verified a commercial benefit.”

This statement buys information. It does not hide an unfavorable result. If the simpler option wins, the bounded AI comparison still demonstrates AI use and evidence-based judgment. You may recommend the simpler option instead of deploying the inferior AI candidate externally.

Now consider a tempting additional feature: the tool automatically changes bookings. It expands permissions, consequences, and testing. Ask whether it is necessary for the selected task. Here it is outside scope; a human handoff completes the process without adding that dependency.

Decision lab · practice with your Learning Companion

The scope negotiation

Define a feasible task, a quality threshold, and a simpler comparison.

Take the role of scope negotiator. Commit to a decision, uncover evidence, revise your reasoning, then carry one action into Build. Use this as the unit’s reasoning rehearsal; reuse the response in your existing project update.

Open the AI Learning Companion section below this interactive lesson to enter this unit’s decision lab. Return here for Build. You can also use the complete reading route below.

Complete reading route · no AI service needed

Fictional teaching scenario. A fictional partner requests “an AI that handles all workshop support.” You have time to test one bounded task. What do you propose?

  1. Handle every question and exception
  2. Draft answers to ordinary questions from approved sources
  3. Make a polished concept deck only

Choose one and write why before revealing the evidence.

Reveal evidence and challenge
Supplied evidence
  • Available information: Only approved ordinary-question information is available; exceptions require an owner.
  • Baseline: A person can answer the same ordinary questions using a template and the source sheet.
  • Quality threshold: The teaching team sets a hypothetical threshold: every critical policy claim must be supported, and missing facts must be flagged.

Negotiate a one-sentence scope. Include an excluded task, a measurable quality check, and the baseline.

Compare with the worked reasoning
Worked reasoning

A testable scope is a reviewed draft for ordinary questions using a named source version. Exclude exception decisions and sending replies. Compare complete effort with the manual template while requiring supported policy claims. A narrower scope is useful when it preserves a real task and makes evidence inspectable.

Apply to your project: Define what your version does, what it refuses or escalates, the simpler alternative, and one quality threshold.

Write your initial choice, evidence-based revision, and project action in your own document.

Practice boundary

Practice records are not grades or Canvas submissions.

Build

Apply this step to your chosen problem. Cedar Desk is the supplied classroom case; keep one project throughout the course.

Prepare Milestone 1: problem and feasible scope

Update the same dossier rather than rewrite the discovery material. Add a three-option comparison and a one-page charter: user, responsible decision owner, need, evidence, current process, chosen AI capability, task, usable output, permitted inputs, no-code route, resources, quality boundary, and exclusions. Explain why the capability fits and what could fail.

Write the decision question in a form a small test can inform: “Can a coordinator produce a source-grounded reply or appropriate exception handoff with less complete effort than the current method on the supplied cases?” Record an important uncertainty and how you will investigate it. “Prove that AI is better” presupposes the answer.

For an instructor-led offering, obtain scope feedback before substantial construction; use the published milestone rubric. While feedback is pending, practice with the supplied case. Self-paced learners compare their charter with the worked example and note the limits of self-review. Keep a brief change log explaining one decision that changed after discovery. The next unit turns the agreed scope into an operating workflow.

Add your project evidence and reflection to the check-in in Canvas.

Your project record

Write here or use your own document. Notes stay in this browser; export a backup to keep them. Nothing is submitted automatically.

Finish

What will you carry forward?

Your Canvas check-in

AI drafting falls from 8 minutes to 2, but checking, correction, and handoff add 6. What full-process claim is supported?

Use the evidence from this lesson to explain your reasoning in Canvas. Continue with Canvas Next below; submit your check-in in Canvas.

The simulation and Learning Companion support practice. They do not submit work, record Canvas completion, or assign a grade.

AI drafting falls from 8 minutes to 2, but checking, correction, and handoff add 6. What full-process claim is supported?

In your project record, state what you decided, the evidence you used, and one uncertainty to test next. Explain the reasoning in your own words.

Milestone 1 of 5

Problem and feasible scope

Save a snapshot of your project record. In a taught offering, submit it using your instructor’s arrangements and apply the feedback before the next dependent task.

Evidence and assessment criteria

Submit or review the first snapshot of the same project record. Show a specific need, the user and responsible decision owner, a traceable evidence log, numerical baseline, three alternatives, a justified AI capability choice, and a bounded charter. Reuse the discovery work rather than write a separate background paper.

A complete classroom case is equivalent to a partner context for practicing these criteria. Label supplied facts, role-play, observations, and assumptions accurately. A compelling technology description without a worthwhile task does not meet the goal.

In an instructor-led offering, obtain scope feedback before substantial building. The rubric weights below divide this milestone; the milestone contributes 15% in the proposed full-course model. Self-paced review does not imply a grade.

Milestone 1 rubric
CriterionMaximum pointsMeets the goalStrong transferScoring anchors
Problem and stakeholder fit25Names a specific user, responsible decision owner, recurring task, consequence, and current alternative.Explains differing stakeholder needs and uses contrary evidence to refine the problem.Strong evidence: 25; Meets the goal: 20; Developing: 12.5; Not demonstrated: 0. Intermediate points within this criterion's maximum are allowed when the instructor explains the criterion-specific evidence.
Evidence and numerical baseline30Important claims have traceable sources or assumption labels; counts, units, denominator, and baseline interpretation are correct.Distinguishes need, performance, and adoption evidence and identifies the missing observation most likely to change the judgment.Strong evidence: 30; Meets the goal: 24; Developing: 15; Not demonstrated: 0. Intermediate points within this criterion's maximum are allowed when the instructor explains the criterion-specific evidence.
Alternatives and feasible scope30Compares current practice, a simple improvement, and an AI candidate with consistent criteria; bounds one task, AI capability, input/output, no-code route, resources, and exclusions.Tests a consequential uncertain assumption and explains why the preferred learning investment changes or remains stable.Strong evidence: 30; Meets the goal: 24; Developing: 15; Not demonstrated: 0. Intermediate points within this criterion's maximum are allowed when the instructor explains the criterion-specific evidence.
Decision and communication15States a testable question, quality boundary, next step, and clear evidence/AI-use disclosure.Makes the chain from evidence to scope easy to inspect and explains a meaningful revision after discovery.Strong evidence: 15; Meets the goal: 12; Developing: 7.5; Not demonstrated: 0. Intermediate points within this criterion's maximum are allowed when the instructor explains the criterion-specific evidence.

How criterion scores are assigned

Each rubric criterion keeps its published maximum points. The instructor judges the evidence against that criterion's Meets the goal and Stronger evidence descriptions and uses these numerical anchors.

Scoring anchors within each criterion's maximum
Evidence levelAnchorWhat the evidence shows
Strong evidence100% of the criterion maximumMeets the goal and demonstrates the criterion's stronger evidence or transfer.
Meets the goal80% of the criterion maximumDemonstrates the stated goal with accurate, usable evidence.
Developing50% of the criterion maximumShows a relevant attempt, but important evidence is incomplete, unreliable, or needs correction.
Not demonstrated0% of the criterion maximumProvides no usable evidence for this criterion.

These are judgment anchors, not automatic all-or-nothing ratings. Intermediate points are allowed within the criterion maximum, with a comment identifying the evidence and remaining gap. For a 25-point criterion the anchors are 25, 20, 12.5 and 0 points. A defensible decision to narrow, revise, or stop can earn strong credit. These anchors do not change criterion maximums, assessment totals, course weights, or previously recorded scores.

A favorable project result is not required; the quality of evidence and judgment matters.

Before saving this snapshot

You can revisit any step. Completion records study progress; it does not confirm a submission, grade, or project quality.