Learn
By the end of this unit
- Demonstrate the actual task and connect the recommendation to traceable evidence.
- Defend a calculation, a design decision, and a limitation without overstating results.
Planned guided work including the short textbook read-and-apply: 83–133 minutes, plus other project work. This is a design estimate, not measured learner time.
How to read this lesson
The labels describe how to use a passage. Color does not prove a claim is true or that a response is correct.
- Explain — Understand the idea.
- Try / predict — Make a choice or prediction before the reveal.
- Evidence — Inspect the named source or supplied data.
- Worked reasoning — Compare the steps after your own attempt.
- Caution — Check a limit, assumption or unsupported conclusion.
Each figure has its own local legend for the data. Blue selection outlines mark the current selection; other outlines are explained by each figure’s local legend. Selection is not a correctness judgment.
Make a decision easy to inspect
The final audience needs to understand what the solution does, what you learned, what it costs, and what should happen next. Lead with a proportionate recommendation. Show the task, sources, and review point. Then use the strongest evidence to explain the recommendation rather than narrating every tool you tried.
A concise decision brief can use six sections: need and alternatives; implemented solution; actual test and revision; impact, resources, and capacity; route to users and operating plan; recommendation and handoff. Keep the artifact, detailed records, and calculations in supporting files. Reuse corrected earlier work and remove claims that later evidence contradicted.
| Proposed claim | Check | Defensible wording |
|---|---|---|
| “The kit is autonomous.” | The workflow requires a reviewer. | “The kit supports a reviewed service.” |
| “People will use it.” | Three supplied respondents would try a pilot. | “The fictional evidence supports further discovery, not validated adoption.” |
| “It saves cash.” | Payroll is unchanged; tools and support cost more. | “It may release capacity under the stated assumptions.” |
| “It was deployed.” | Was a version actually accessible and used? | State the real delivery location, task, user role, and limits. |
A figure should make the comparison clearer. The supplied 96-to 84-minute benchmark is a 12.5% reduction. A bar chart beginning at 80 can exaggerate the visual gap; label any restricted axis and prefer a zero baseline for these magnitude bars. Keep the table available, identify the twelve supplied cases, and show quality alongside time. Your own pilot figure must use your actual observations.
Model opening: evidence-supported caution
“I recommend a bounded next test of the reviewed ReplyKit, not a broad rollout yet. The supplied benchmark shows twelve acceptable replies with less complete effort than the manual comparison. That is classroom case evidence, not our own deployment or evidence of wider use. The monthly base scenario has zero net capacity value and negative cash change. Our next decision depends on observed use, review effort, and quality.”
Adapt the structure to your actual project. Replace supplied evidence with your observed record where available, keep the distinction visible, and do not copy an event you did not perform.
See the decision
The chart changes. The evidence does not.
Predict whether changing the axis can change the actual percentage reduction.
Use the same supplied 12-case benchmark:96 manual minutes,84 reviewed-AI minutes, and 12/12 acceptable replies for both policies.
| Policy | Complete effort | Acceptable replies |
|---|---|---|
| Manual | 96 minutes | 12/12 |
| Reviewed AI | 84 minutes | 12/12 |
The actual reduction is 12/96=12.5%. Starting the axis at 80 leaves visible bar lengths 16 and 4: the second visible length is 75%shorter, although the data did not change. This comparison supports a limited complete-effort claim, not guaranteed cash savings, future reliability, or market demand.
Use it in your project: Audit one figure in your demonstration: identify its baseline, units, denominator, evidence setting, and a claim it cannot support.
Required textbook reading and application · about 18 minutes
Read, then apply one idea
Read only the passages listed here. Mathematical derivations, algorithms, code, and end-of-chapter exercises are not assigned. The time estimate includes the brief passage and one connection to your existing project update; reading the passage alone usually takes much less time. It is a planning estimate, not a timer.
1.6.3: Defining a Solution
David L. Poole and Alan K. Mackworth. Artificial Intelligence: Foundations of Computational Agents. 3rd edition. Cambridge University Press, 2023.
Read: Revisit the same section 1.6.3 passage assigned in Unit 3: heading through the Satisficing solution entry, stopping before Approximately optimal solution. This is a review, not a new whole-section assignment.
Why this unit: Connects the final demonstration to the success criteria set before building.
7.3: Developing Pitches for Various Audiences and Goals
Michael Laverty and Chris Littel. Entrepreneurship. 1st edition. OpenStax, Rice University, 2020.
Read: Read the introductory discussion before Table 7.3 and the first paragraph under Pitch Audiences. Skip the table's specific timings, investor fundraising sections and external videos.
Why this unit: Adapt a concise problem/solution explanation and specific request to its audience.
Course connection: Defend the result using the original need, acceptance rule, observed use, revision, and retest. Separate demonstrated behavior from an unimplemented plan and identify remaining risks. A credible final recommendation can be to continue, revise, limit, or stop the solution.
Course connection: A request can be for a classroom review, an approved pilot, feedback or continued use. Investment, a company, a sale and a public launch are not required.
Apply one idea: Choose one prompt for the brief connection in your existing project update.
- Give your final recommendation and support it with one measured result, one demonstrated change, and one remaining limitation. Explain who owns the next decision and why the evidence is sufficient for that limited next step.
- Name your audience, the evidence it needs and one proportionate next request.
Read this textbook section here
The official page below may include material before or after your assigned selection. The reader does not automatically scroll or crop to that selection.
Assigned selection — 1.6.3: Defining a Solution: Revisit the same section 1.6.3 passage assigned in Unit 3: heading through the Satisficing solution entry, stopping before Approximately optimal solution. This is a review, not a new whole-section assignment.
Read this textbook section here
The official page below may include material before or after your assigned selection. The reader does not automatically scroll or crop to that selection.
Assigned selection — 7.3: Developing Pitches for Various Audiences and Goals: Read the introductory discussion before Table 7.3 and the first paragraph under Pitch Audiences. Skip the table's specific timings, investor fundraising sections and external videos.
Add a brief connection to your existing project update: identify the book and section, explain one relevant idea in your own words, and show the decision it informs. This is part of the same update, not another assignment.
If the official reader is unavailable or inaccessible, use the original lesson explanation and worked example, apply the same question, and label that access alternative honestly. Report the problem through the course support route; do not claim to have read an unavailable text.
Optional further reading
Strategyzer — How to select the next best test ↗
Read the experiment-selection principles and the discovery/validation distinction. Name the uncertainty your next test addresses. The article’s suggested experiment cadence is not an added course requirement.
Try
Rehearse the decision, then change one assumption
Give a short demonstration: locate the source, enter an ordinary or exception question, produce the useful output, show the human check, and locate the record. A video or screenshots can support access needs, but the usable artifact and actual task evidence must still be available.
Ask a reviewer to challenge one assumption: “What if adoption is 30%?”, “What if review adds six minutes?”, or “What if the user prefers the existing template?” Answer with the relevant calculation or evidence limit. A clear “we have not established that” is more defensible than an invented answer.
Worked changed-assumption answer
For the supplied monthly scenario,30% of 1,200 is 360 assisted replies. One minute each releases six hours, valued at $144. After $240 recurring expense, net capacity value is − $96. With unchanged payroll, recurring cash change remains − $240. This weakens the value case; it does not prove that every possible use is worthless.
Decision lab · practice with your Learning Companion
The skeptical handoff
Defend a proportionate recommendation with calculations, limits, and an operating owner.
Take the role of decision defender. Commit to a decision, uncover evidence, revise your reasoning, then carry one action into Build. Use this as the unit’s reasoning rehearsal; reuse the response in your existing project update.
Open the AI Learning Companion section below this interactive lesson to enter this unit’s decision lab. Return here for Build. You can also use the complete reading route below.
Complete reading route · no AI service needed
Fictional teaching scenario. A fictional team shows 96-to-84-minute complete effort on twelve supplied cases and asks to claim “autonomous, profitable, ready for everyone.” Choose the recommendation.
- Approve the headline because the demo works
- Recommend a bounded next test with explicit limits and ownership
- Hide the unfavorable scenario
Choose one and write why before revealing the evidence.
Reveal evidence and challenge
- Performance: 84 vs 96 minutes is 12 minutes less, a 12.5% reduction on these twelve supplied cases; quality must be shown alongside it.
- Value challenge: At 30% of 1,200 monthly replies and one minute saved, six hours are valued at $144. Less $240 recurring expense gives −$96 net capacity value; unchanged payroll means −$240 recurring cash change.
- Handoff challenge: A reviewer is required. The next owner must locate the source version, instructions, exception route, and stop conditions.
Give a three-sentence defense: recommendation, strongest evidence with its limit, and the next test with an owner. What would change your recommendation?
Compare with the worked reasoning
A defensible recommendation is a bounded next test of a reviewed workflow. The supplied comparison shows 12.5% lower complete effort on these twelve cases. Proceeding depends on confirming that both methods met the same quality threshold: acceptable-output counts are not provided here. The changed-use scenario weakens the value case. These are fictional course data, not the team’s observed deployment. A handoff needs an accessible artifact, approved sources, review and exception ownership, support boundaries, and a decision trigger.
Apply to your project: Write your own recommendation, one traceable calculation, one evidence limit, and the person or role owning the next decision.
Write your initial choice, evidence-based revision, and project action in your own document.
Practice records are not grades or Canvas submissions.
Build
Apply this step to your chosen problem. Cedar Desk is the supplied classroom case; keep one project throughout the course.
Prepare Milestone 5: demonstration and handoff
Assemble the current usable artifact, concise decision brief, six-to-eight-slide deck or accessible equivalent, actual test/retest record, impact/resources page, and operating pack. In an instructor-led offering, use the announced submission and presentation arrangements. Study progress on the website is not a submission or grade.
Every learner should explain a calculation, a consequential design choice, and an evidence limit using their contribution. The individual checks near Milestones 3 and 5 provide this evidence; the team’s polish does not substitute for individual understanding. Self-paced learners can record the same explanation and compare it with the rubric, without implying an instructor award.
Check access to the handoff files and state what happens after the course: permitted continued use, owner, support boundary, unresolved issues, and closeout. A well-supported decision to narrow or stop can earn strong evaluation when the implementation, test, revision, and reasoning are complete. Finish with the specific next action, who owns it, and what evidence would change the decision.
Add your project evidence and reflection to the check-in in Canvas.
Your project record
Write here or use your own document. Notes stay in this browser; export a backup to keep them. Nothing is submitted automatically.
Finish
What will you carry forward?
Your Canvas check-in
Your classroom test succeeds, but continued use and review effort remain uncertain. Which final recommendation best matches the evidence?
Use the evidence from this lesson to explain your reasoning in Canvas. Continue with Canvas Next below; submit your check-in in Canvas.
The simulation and Learning Companion support practice. They do not submit work, record Canvas completion, or assign a grade.
In your project record, state what you decided, the evidence you used, and one uncertainty to test next. Explain the reasoning in your own words.
Milestone 5 of 5
Demonstration and handoff
Save a snapshot of your project record. In a taught offering, submit it using your instructor’s arrangements and apply the feedback before the next dependent task.
Evidence and assessment criteria
Demonstrate the actual bounded task and defend the recommendation using the artifact, test/retest evidence, impact/resources, and operating handoff. Provide a concise decision brief and presentation or an accessible equivalent using the offering’s announced arrangements.
This milestone’s internal rubric allocates 60% to the shared demonstration/handoff and 40% to the individual case exam. In the full-course model, those contribute 15 and 10 percentage points respectively. The case exam is the sole assessed individual component; earlier explanations are ungraded preparation and are not included again. Every learner explains a calculation, a decision, and a limitation. Self-paced completion does not imply instructor grading or a credential.
| Criterion | Maximum points | Meets the goal | Strong transfer | Scoring anchors |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Demonstration and evidence-backed recommendation | 25 | Shows a usable task, actual testing and revision, clear alternatives, and a recommendation proportionate to the evidence. | Connects a changed-case demonstration and the strongest contrary evidence to a well-justified next decision. | Strong evidence: 25; Meets the goal: 20; Developing: 12.5; Not demonstrated: 0. Intermediate points within this criterion's maximum are allowed when the instructor explains the criterion-specific evidence. |
| Operating handoff and continued use | 20 | Recipient can locate current files, sources, instructions, owner, review/exception rules, support limits, and post-course status. | A handoff trial exposes and corrects a practical issue; maintenance and closeout choices fit the actual resources. | Strong evidence: 20; Meets the goal: 16; Developing: 10; Not demonstrated: 0. Intermediate points within this criterion's maximum are allowed when the instructor explains the criterion-specific evidence. |
| Clear communication and evidence | 15 | Concise brief and presentation use readable figures, correct units and baselines, honest claims, and a specific request. | The audience can inspect the claim-to-evidence chain and understand a material tradeoff without hidden assumptions. | Strong evidence: 15; Meets the goal: 12; Developing: 7.5; Not demonstrated: 0. Intermediate points within this criterion's maximum are allowed when the instructor explains the criterion-specific evidence. |
| Individual quantitative understanding | 20 | Each learner explains a relevant calculation, units, denominator, and what changes under a new assumption. | Identifies an alternative interpretation or misleading metric and connects the correction to the decision. | Strong evidence: 20; Meets the goal: 16; Developing: 10; Not demonstrated: 0. Intermediate points within this criterion's maximum are allowed when the instructor explains the criterion-specific evidence. |
| Individual design judgment and ownership | 20 | Each learner explains a personal contribution, consequential design choice, evidence limit, and appropriate human responsibility. | Defends a revision against a plausible alternative and transfers the reasoning to a changed real-world condition. | Strong evidence: 20; Meets the goal: 16; Developing: 10; Not demonstrated: 0. Intermediate points within this criterion's maximum are allowed when the instructor explains the criterion-specific evidence. |
How criterion scores are assigned
Each rubric criterion keeps its published maximum points. The instructor judges the evidence against that criterion's Meets the goal and Stronger evidence descriptions and uses these numerical anchors.
| Evidence level | Anchor | What the evidence shows |
|---|---|---|
| Strong evidence | 100% of the criterion maximum | Meets the goal and demonstrates the criterion's stronger evidence or transfer. |
| Meets the goal | 80% of the criterion maximum | Demonstrates the stated goal with accurate, usable evidence. |
| Developing | 50% of the criterion maximum | Shows a relevant attempt, but important evidence is incomplete, unreliable, or needs correction. |
| Not demonstrated | 0% of the criterion maximum | Provides no usable evidence for this criterion. |
These are judgment anchors, not automatic all-or-nothing ratings. Intermediate points are allowed within the criterion maximum, with a comment identifying the evidence and remaining gap. For a 25-point criterion the anchors are 25, 20, 12.5 and 0 points. A defensible decision to narrow, revise, or stop can earn strong credit. These anchors do not change criterion maximums, assessment totals, course weights, or previously recorded scores.
A favorable project result is not required; the quality of evidence and judgment matters.
Before saving this snapshot
You can revisit any step. Completion records study progress; it does not confirm a submission, grade, or project quality.